Medical professionalism and Health Humanities
What the study of literature can contribute to the conversation
Articolo di BioMed Central
Over the past fifty years the study of literature has become a generally accepted aspect of medical education. As thoughtful scholars have recently considered how to teach professionalism effectively and meaningfully, questions have arisen about the role of stories, essays, first-person narratives, and poetry in facilitating the professional identity formation of medical students. Those who argue affirmatively imply that exposing students to literature will inculcate professionalism virtues and attributes [1]. Those who disagree assert that the study of literature has goals and purposes unrelated to professionalism [2]. In this article, we investigate definitions of medical professionalism, and frame its inclusion in the competency framework as an effort to anchor its abstract virtues in behavioral specificity. Next we consider how literature can advance our understanding of medical professionalism through a different kind of singularity grounded in the literary method of close reading. Ultimately, we contend that the development of medical professionalism will benefit from the critical and interrogative methods of literature.
This article is a result of the Project to Rebalance and Integrate Medical Education (PRIME), sponsored by the Patrick and Edna Romanell Foundation. PRIME focused on how medical ethics and humanities education are prerequisite to professionalism formation in medical school and residency training [3, 4]. PRIME, in turn, resulted in the creation of the Academy for Professionalism in Health Care as an organization devoted to professionalism education [5].
The conundrum of professionalism in medical education
There are at least two significant issues to consider in discussing medical professionalism. One has to do with the contentof professionalism itself, i.e., how it is defined. The second is essentially an implementation issue, i.e., the methods which establish how professionalism is achieved. These issues, and their implications for professionalism education, are discussed below.
Defining medical professionalism
The Medical Professionalism Project initiated by the American Board of Internal Medicine Foundation, the American College of Physicians Foundation, and the European Federation of Internal Medicine resulted in a professionalism charter consisting of virtue-based attributes such as altruism, trust, honesty, patient empowerment, and commitment to social justice [6]. Medical educatorshave also argued for a virtue-based definition, including qualities of compassion, integrity; truth-telling; respect for others; self-effacement; and fidelity to patients [7–10]. Prior PRIME publications acknowledged the importance of scientific and clinical competence using established rigorous evidence-based medicine; while emphasizingpromotion of patients’ best interests as the clinician’s primary moral consideration (with self-interest as a subservient claim) and honoring the exercise of the public trust, as a necessary obligation to carry forth the fiduciary traditions of medicine (as opposed to guild-like self-interest) [4]. Other definitions also support the commitment to and reinforcement of moral values and ethical principles [11, 12].
These definitions, while valuable, highlighted primarily general, abstract virtues and attributes that have proved difficult to translate into daily actions. Recent considerations of professionalism and professional identity formation have stressed the necessity of moving from abstraction to practice [13, 14], highlighting what is often referred to as phronesis or practical wisdom [15]. Medical educators have wrestled with this challenge for the past decade, most notably through the effort to incorporate medical professionalism into the competency framework.
Professionalism as a competency
Indeed, it could be argued that the rise of the competency movement in medical education [16] has been an effort to anchor generalities of training in specific, concrete, measurable behaviors. In terms of professionalism specifically, attempting to inculcate values and virtues often struck both learners and educators as threatening and potentially implying character defects in students [17]. Thus, professionalism moved from the conceptual realm to become one of six essential medical education competencies, sometimes viewed as a “meta”- or “ordering” contextual competency for more technical competencies [18, 19]. In this respect, competency-based education appeared to offer a “solution” to the abstract nature of earlier approaches to conceptualizing professionalism, precisely because of its behavioral specificity. Many medical educators found the notion of professional competencies appealing because they seemed to offer the promise of transforming amorphous, ill-defined, and difficult-to-measure qualities into instrumental behaviors that were observable and assessable. Recently more detailed “milestones” have been added to supplement and refine the six competencies, but these remainrooted in the establishment of measurable behavior [20]. Whether discussing milestones or competencies, the language employed reflects a tendency in these guidelines to prescribe, control, and shape learners in specific, reductive directions.
Challenging a behavioral approach to medical professionalism
Even as professionalism became identified as an area of medical competence, some medical educators’ reflections on the topic continued to reveal a discomfort with behavioral pedagogical approaches, instead advocating for developing, reinforcing, and sustaining deeply held attitudes and values [17, 21]. As Hanna and Fins write, medical students must learn how to “be good doctors”, rather than merely to act like good doctors [18, 22, 23]”.
Others also assert that behavioral professionalism tempts students to behave in ways that fulfill others’ expectations of professionalism without actually believing in the virtues or principles that underpin these behaviors [24], resulting in an emphasis on surface impression management [25]. Others complain that in clinical settings, professionalism is simplistically and narrowly defined as a technical problem, with most solutions offered being prescriptive, mechanical, and rule-bound [26]. continua a leggere
Trackbacks & Pingbacks
find someone to write my paper https://writingpaperservice.net/
can i pay someone to write my paper https://cheapcustompaper.org/
thesis paper help https://top100custompapernapkins.com/
write my paper for money https://doyourpapersonline.com/
write my paper https://write-my-paper-for-me.org/
college papers help https://paperwritinghq.com/
buy custom paper https://term-paper-help.org/
gay incest chat https://gayinteracialchat.com/
live gay web cam chat rooms https://free-gay-sex-chat.com/
sacramento gay chat https://gaymusclechatrooms.com/
best gay chat https://gaychatnorules.com/
free phx gay chat https://gayphillychat.com/
gay cam chat webcam https://chatcongays.com/
gay incest chat https://gay-live-chat.net/
chat random gay chat https://gaychatspots.com/
gay chat sites https://gaychatcams.net/
gay universe man chat https://newgaychat.com/
online casino in usa https://casinosonlinex.com/
online casino bonuses no deposit https://online2casino.com/
dating personal https://zonlinedating.com/
dating site for https://virtual-online-dating-service.com/
interracial dating https://lavaonlinedating.com/
adoult dating https://wowdatingsites.com/
local singles https://datingpersonalsonline.com/
free onilne dating https://online-internet-dating.net/
sex dating sights https://adult-classifieds-online-dating.com/
free online dating site https://adult-singles-online-dating.com/
zoosk online dating site https://onlinedatingbabes.com/
free se4x https://freephotodating.com/
is it smart for gay teens to use dating apps https://gayedating.com/
gay dating https://gay-singles-dating.com/
buy cyberghost vpn https://free-vpn-proxy.com/
completely free vpn https://superfreevpn.net/
best vpn service 2019 https://ippowervpn.net/
proton vpn free https://shiva-vpn.com/
river casino online https://casino8online.com/
golden eagle casino online https://all-online-casino-games.com/
firekeepers online casino https://ownonlinecasino.com/
usa online casino real money https://onlineplayerscasino.com/
online casino for real money no deposit https://casino-online-jackpot.com/
gta online casino heist https://casino-online-roulette.com/
goldennugget online casino https://vrgamescasino.com/
sugarhouse casino online sportsbook https://1freeslotscasino.com/
top online casino review https://cybertimeonlinecasino.com/
online casino hosting sanjeev beemidi https://internet-casinos-online.net/
jacks casino online https://free-online-casinos.net/
zone casino online https://9lineslotscasino.com/
online casino virginia https://onlinecasinosdirectory.org/
best online casino for usa players https://trust-online-casino.com/
new online casino real money https://newlasvegascasinos.com/
lady luck casino online https://onlinecasinofortunes.com/
betmgm casino online https://download-casino-slots.com/
3incorporeal
phd dissertation help outline https://helpon-doctoral-dissertations.net/
help writing dissertation https://mydissertationwritinghelp.com/
how to cite a dissertation https://help-with-dissertations.com/
doctoral dissertation help 6th https://dissertationwriting-service.com/
king kong slots https://slotmachinegameinfo.com/
sharknado slots in vegas https://www-slotmachines.com/
slots lotty manna https://411slotmachine.com/
what slots pay the most https://download-slot-machines.com/
double diamond free slots https://beat-slot-machines.com/
google free slots https://slotmachinesforum.net/
las vegas casino slots https://slotmachinesworld.com/
doubledown casino slots https://pennyslotmachines.org/
bier haus slots https://candylandslotmachine.com/
free slots for pc https://freeonlneslotmachine.com/
free slots for pc https://2-free-slots.com/
gay dating 70 https://speedgaydate.com/
chat gay en espanol gratis https://gaytgpost.com/
random gay cam chat https://bjsgaychatroom.info/
3syracuse
Viagra order
Low cost canadian viagra
Viagra overnight shipping
Real viagra
Overnight delivery viagra
Free viagra
Generic viagra canada
Best prices on viagra
cialistodo.com
Medical professionalism and Health Humanities | Digital Narrative Medicine
viagra pills 100 mg
Medical professionalism and Health Humanities | Digital Narrative Medicine
price sildenafil citrate walmart
Medical professionalism and Health Humanities | Digital Narrative Medicine
cialis buy cialis online
tadalafil cialis
cheap viagra online
online viagra
canadian pharmacy viagra
order viagra online
viagra online usa
viagra dosage
online casino gambling
casino gambling
gambling games
rivers casino
online casinos
best casino online
online casino games real money
online casinos usa
cialis 5 mg
cialis buy
cialis 5 mg
5 mg cialis
cialis internet
generic for cialis
cialis to buy
cialis 20
viagra for sale
viagra pills
loans for bad credit
instant loans
online payday loans
online payday loans
cash payday
short term loans
real money casino
online casino games real money
online casino games
casino online games for real money
generic viagra cost
viagra online usa
best online casino real money
win real money online casino for free
online casinos real money
casino online games
buy levitra online
levitra pill
vardenafil 20mg
online levitra
buy vardenafil online
levitra usa
generic cialis
Buy cialis online
cialis online
cialis visa
pharmacy online
walmart pharmacy
pharmacy online
canadian online pharmacy
canada online pharmacy
online pharmacy
cialis online
generic cialis online
buy erection pills
top rated ed pills
erection pills viagra online
generic ed pills
pills erectile dysfunction
ed pills online
sildenafil online
Order Viagra Online
I commenti sono chiusi.