Medical professionalism and Health Humanities

What the study of literature can contribute to the conversation


Articolo di BioMed Central

Over the past fifty years the study of literature has become a generally accepted aspect of medical education. As thoughtful scholars have recently considered how to teach professionalism effectively and meaningfully, questions have arisen about the role of stories, essays, first-person narratives, and poetry in facilitating the professional identity formation of medical students. Those who argue affirmatively imply that exposing students to literature will inculcate professionalism virtues and attributes [1]. Those who disagree assert that the study of literature has goals and purposes unrelated to professionalism [2]. In this article, we investigate definitions of medical professionalism, and frame its inclusion in the competency framework as an effort to anchor its abstract virtues in behavioral specificity. Next we consider how literature can advance our understanding of medical professionalism through a different kind of singularity grounded in the literary method of close reading. Ultimately, we contend that the development of medical professionalism will benefit from the critical and interrogative methods of literature.

This article is a result of the Project to Rebalance and Integrate Medical Education (PRIME), sponsored by the Patrick and Edna Romanell Foundation. PRIME focused on how medical ethics and humanities education are prerequisite to professionalism formation in medical school and residency training [3, 4]. PRIME, in turn, resulted in the creation of the Academy for Professionalism in Health Care as an organization devoted to professionalism education [5].

The conundrum of professionalism in medical education

There are at least two significant issues to consider in discussing medical professionalism. One has to do with the contentof professionalism itself, i.e., how it is defined. The second is essentially an implementation issue, i.e., the methods which establish how professionalism is achieved. These issues, and their implications for professionalism education, are discussed below.

Defining medical professionalism

The Medical Professionalism Project initiated by the American Board of Internal Medicine Foundation, the American College of Physicians Foundation, and the European Federation of Internal Medicine resulted in a professionalism charter consisting of virtue-based attributes such as altruism, trust, honesty, patient empowerment, and commitment to social justice [6]. Medical educatorshave also argued for a virtue-based definition, including qualities of compassion, integrity; truth-telling; respect for others; self-effacement; and fidelity to patients [710]. Prior PRIME publications acknowledged the importance of scientific and clinical competence using established rigorous evidence-based medicine; while emphasizingpromotion of patients’ best interests as the clinician’s primary moral consideration (with self-interest as a subservient claim) and honoring the exercise of the public trust, as a necessary obligation to carry forth the fiduciary traditions of medicine (as opposed to guild-like self-interest) [4]. Other definitions also support the commitment to and reinforcement of moral values and ethical principles [11, 12].

These definitions, while valuable, highlighted primarily general, abstract virtues and attributes that have proved difficult to translate into daily actions. Recent considerations of professionalism and professional identity formation have stressed the necessity of moving from abstraction to practice [13, 14], highlighting what is often referred to as phronesis or practical wisdom [15]. Medical educators have wrestled with this challenge for the past decade, most notably through the effort to incorporate medical professionalism into the competency framework.

Professionalism as a competency

Indeed, it could be argued that the rise of the competency movement in medical education [16] has been an effort to anchor generalities of training in specific, concrete, measurable behaviors. In terms of professionalism specifically, attempting to inculcate values and virtues often struck both learners and educators as threatening and potentially implying character defects in students [17]. Thus, professionalism moved from the conceptual realm to become one of six essential medical education competencies, sometimes viewed as a “meta”- or “ordering” contextual competency for more technical competencies [18, 19]. In this respect, competency-based education appeared to offer a “solution” to the abstract nature of earlier approaches to conceptualizing professionalism, precisely because of its behavioral specificity. Many medical educators found the notion of professional competencies appealing because they seemed to offer the promise of transforming amorphous, ill-defined, and difficult-to-measure qualities into instrumental behaviors that were observable and assessable. Recently more detailed “milestones” have been added to supplement and refine the six competencies, but these remainrooted in the establishment of measurable behavior [20]. Whether discussing milestones or competencies, the language employed reflects a tendency in these guidelines to prescribe, control, and shape learners in specific, reductive directions.

Challenging a behavioral approach to medical professionalism

Even as professionalism became identified as an area of medical competence, some medical educators’ reflections on the topic continued to reveal a discomfort with behavioral pedagogical approaches, instead advocating for developing, reinforcing, and sustaining deeply held attitudes and values [17, 21]. As Hanna and Fins write, medical students must learn how to “be good doctors”, rather than merely to act like good doctors [18, 22, 23]”.

Others also assert that behavioral professionalism tempts students to behave in ways that fulfill others’ expectations of professionalism without actually believing in the virtues or principles that underpin these behaviors [24], resulting in an emphasis on surface impression management [25]. Others complain that in clinical settings, professionalism is simplistically and narrowly defined as a technical problem, with most solutions offered being prescriptive, mechanical, and rule-bound [26]. continua a leggere

113 commenti

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. is it smart for gay teens to use dating apps https://gayedating.com/

  2. Viagra order

    Low cost canadian viagra

  3. Viagra overnight shipping

    Real viagra

  4. Overnight delivery viagra

    Free viagra

  5. Generic viagra canada

    Best prices on viagra

  6. cialistodo.com scrive:


    Medical professionalism and Health Humanities | Digital Narrative Medicine

  7. viagra pills 100 mg

    Medical professionalism and Health Humanities | Digital Narrative Medicine

  8. price sildenafil citrate walmart

    Medical professionalism and Health Humanities | Digital Narrative Medicine

  9. cialis buy cialis online

    tadalafil cialis

  10. cheap viagra online

    online viagra

  11. canadian pharmacy viagra

    order viagra online

  12. viagra online usa

    viagra dosage

  13. casinos online scrive:

    online casino gambling

    casino gambling

  14. gambling games

    rivers casino

  15. online casinos

    best casino online

  16. casino scrive:

    online casino games real money

    online casinos usa

  17. cialis internet scrive:

    cialis 5 mg

    cialis buy

  18. cialis internet scrive:

    cialis 5 mg

    5 mg cialis

  19. cialis internet scrive:

    cialis internet

    generic for cialis

  20. 5 mg cialis scrive:

    cialis to buy

    cialis 20

  21. viagra for sale scrive:

    viagra for sale

    viagra pills

  22. loan online scrive:

    loans for bad credit

    instant loans

  23. online payday loans

    online payday loans

  24. cash loan scrive:

    cash payday

    short term loans

  25. real money casino

    online casino games real money

  26. slots online scrive:

    online casino games

    casino online games for real money

  27. generic viagra cost

    viagra online usa

  28. best online casino real money

    win real money online casino for free

  29. casinos scrive:

    online casinos real money

    casino online games

  30. vardenafil usa scrive:

    buy levitra online

    levitra pill

  31. levitra cost scrive:

    vardenafil 20mg

    online levitra

  32. vardenafil scrive:

    buy vardenafil online

    levitra usa

  33. generic cialis scrive:

    generic cialis

    Buy cialis online

  34. cialis online

    cialis visa

  35. pharmacy online

    walmart pharmacy

  36. pharmacy online

    canadian online pharmacy

  37. canada online pharmacy

    online pharmacy

  38. cialis online scrive:

    cialis online

    generic cialis online

  39. buy erection pills

    top rated ed pills

  40. erection pills viagra online

    generic ed pills

  41. ed pills gnc scrive:

    pills erectile dysfunction

    ed pills online

  42. sildenafil online

    Order Viagra Online

I commenti sono chiusi.