Ten Commandments for patient-centred treatment

Il British Journal of General Practice pubblica un decalogo per il medico di medicina generale che rievoca le tavole della legge, per un trattamento che non perda mai di vista la prospettiva del paziente.

Articolo condiviso dal British Journal



1. Thou shalt have no aim except to help patients, according to the goals they wish to achieve

When deciding on a treatment, the first diagnosis you need to reach is about the nature of the illness. The second diagnosis you need concerns what the individual would like to achieve.1 Both are of equal importance and this is as true in simple one-off encounters as in complex lifelong illness. But the balance needs particularly careful thought when beginning long-term treatment.

Always make sure that you understand your patient’s aims before you propose a course of action. It may require 3 minutes in a situation like an acute sore throat, or years of ongoing dialogue in a situation like multiple sclerosis or heart failure. Do not assume that you know what your patient has come for, and do not assume that the treatments you have on offer meet the goals of everyone in the same way.

2. Thou shalt always seek knowledge of the benefits, harms, and costs of treatment, and share this knowledge at all times

Both health professionals and lay people tend to overestimate the benefits of treatments and underestimate their harms. The traditional way to express these is as the number-needed-to-treat (NNT) and the number-needed-to-harm (NNH).

It is important to have a ‘ball-park’ idea of these figures in common clinical situations, but also important to bear in mind their limitations. First, patients mostly find NNTs and NNHs hard to understand.2 Second, the numbers do not apply to individuals equally but are just average figures across the populations of clinical trials. Third, people vary widely in how they would balance a given benefit against a given harm.3

So we need better ways of a) knowing the true NNT and the NNH in the populations we treat; b) sharing this knowledge with people in ways they can understand; and c) applying this knowledge to the goals and preferences of the individual in front of us.

3. Thou shalt, if all else fails or if the evidence is lacking, happily consider watchful waiting as an appropriate course of action

The first commandment assumes that there will be two diagnoses in each consultation. But often there will be more, or none.

Many consultations consist of a complex dialogue of exploration, attempted understanding, and partial uncertainty. Unless there is a clear diagnosis, it is usually better to keep the offer open of another consultation rather than issue a prescription.

Other situations where it is often better not to prescribe include acute self-limiting illnesses where symptomatic treatments are available over the counter (OTC). This also applies to some more chronic conditions such as irritable bowel syndrome and chronic back pain, which characteristically fluctuate and for which prescription-only treatments are usually no more effective than cheap OTC alternatives.

The temptation to prescribe rather than offer a timely reassessment should always be resisted. continua a leggere

24 commenti

Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. new cialis scrive:

    5 mg cialis

    cialis 5 mg

  2. cialis to buy scrive:

    cialis buy

    cialis 5 mg

  3. 20 cialis scrive:

    cialis 5 mg

    buy cialis

  4. viagra prescription

    viagra pills

  5. loans online scrive:

    cash loan

    cash payday

  6. cash payday scrive:

    pay day loans

    loans online

  7. online loans scrive:

    installment loans

    loans online

  8. online slots for real money

    slot machines

  9. casino real money

    slot machine games

  10. canadian viagra

    cheapest viagra online

  11. online casino usa real money

    real money online casino

  12. free slots online

    caesars casino online

  13. levitra online pharmacy

    vardenafil online pharmacy

  14. online vardenafil

    online vardenafil

  15. cheap levitra scrive:

    levitra 20 mg

    levitra generic

  16. Buy cialis

    Buy cheap cialis

  17. generic cialis online

    Buy cheap cialis

  18. rx pharmacy

    cvs pharmacy

  19. online pharmacy scrive:

    cvs pharmacy

    online pharmacy

  20. cialis for sale scrive:

    cialis generic

    cialis 10mg

  21. new ed pills

    erectile dysfunction pills

  22. ed meds online without doctor prescription

    generic ed pills

  23. erection pills scrive:

    new ed pills

    over the counter erectile dysfunction pills

  24. buy sildenafil scrive:

    Order Viagra Online

    sildenafil online

I commenti sono chiusi.